Presbytery Meeting Summary – March 11, 2025
The fourth anniversary of the Presbytery of the Highlands of New Jersey was celebrated on March 11, a blend of important work and commemoration. This was the first Presbtery meeting of 2025, as Highlands is experimenting with four meetings annually — in March, May, September, and November — rather than five. This was also the first meeting for the Revs. Chad Rodgers (Validated) and Ryon Herin (Rockaway) to preside as Moderator and Vice-Moderator respectively.
In this year when the Presbytery’s Discernment Process comes to full flower, the day kicked off 2025’s year-long theme: a walk through the new Vocation Statement.
The focus of this year’s first meeting is the first line: “God calls the Presbytery of the Highlands.” You can watch this meeting in its entirety, and watch or skip to particular segments, by going to the Presbytery’s website here.
The Presbytery was pleased to welcome several guests, beginning with the Rev. Dr. Carrie Mitchell, Regional Representative, Board of Pensions, and Member of Coastlands Presbytery. Carrie brought greeting from the Board before giving a brief review of the Board’s long and valuable history. She also shared two new initiatives, the first being a new partnership with Spring Health for mental health services. She also described a new grant of $10,000 for up to three years, designed for two congregations to partner as a means to provide Board of Pensions coverage for a single pastor. You can get more information on these and everything else the Board of Pensions provides by going to www.pensions.org/, emailing info@pensions.org, or calling 800-773-7752.
Worship was led by members of the Presbytery’s Permanent Judicial Commission, Revs. Tom Brown (Chatham Township), David Harvey (Blairstown), Linda Gaden (Bethlehem), and Ruling Elder Jamie Evans (Flemington). David preached on Matthew 13:1-9, through the lens of the Vocation Statement’s first line, “God calls the Presbytery of the Highlands.” He spoke of his many years in Newton and n0w Highlands Presbytery, his involvement in a variety of committees, including the current Administration and Coordinating Team, through the lens of his participation in the Discernment Team’s work over the past 18 months.
Members of the Presbytery’s Worship Planning Team also participated in worship, with Revs. Mary Beth Mardis-Lecroy (Old Greenwich) and Ryon Herin (Rockaway) presenting the Necrology. Many found the Necrology particularly moving, and congregations are encouraged to share it with their members; this Celebration of the Saints can be found here.
Ruling Elder Pete Peterson (Clinton), Co-Moderator of the Administration and Coordinating Team gave reason for celebration in the Presbytery’s fourth anniversary, as the Presbytery’s giving far exceeded expectations. Because of the 2021 transition, a gradually declining deficit has been planned for; for 2024, that anticipated deficit was $61,000. Thanks to the generosity of our churches, that deficit proved to be only $20,000, a savings of $41,000. Per Capita contributions were $25,000 more than budgeted, plus $3000 more in missional giving.
Pete also introduced Susan Johnson as the Presbytery’s new Financial Administrator. Susan is a life-long New Jersey resident, a member of the Community Presbyterian Church of Chester, and someone with long experience in financial administration. You can reach her at financeadmin@highlandspresbyterynj.org with questions or to send your greetings.
The Presbytery then celebrated the long and indispensible ministry of Liz Hutchinson, whose nineteen years as the Presbytery’s Financial Administrator conclude at the end of March. Presbytery Treasurer Becky Moody (Madison) shared comments from many who worked with, and benefited from, Liz’s expertise and gracious spirit. With the assistance of Liz’s husband, the Presbytery was able to present her with a gift of appreciation in real time.
Following all of the well wishes, Presbytery Leader Jeanne Radak updated the Presbytery on the Discernment Process, beginning with the aforementioned Vocation Statement. A last retreat is planned for finalizing the report, before discussion and vote at the hybrid May 13 Presbytery meeting (Zoom and Camp Johnsonburg).
Stated Clerk Steve Shussett opened the formal process of voting on proposed amendments to the Book of Order. He noted that following the General Assembly, there are proposed amendments to the Book of Order, and other matters which require approval by a majority of the 166 presbyteries Out of the 226th General Assembly in 2024, there are a total of twelve amendments and one ecumenical agreement for all presbyteries to consider.
Steve thanked Ruling Elders Craig Barth (Morristown) and Alec Jain (Morris Plains), and Teaching Elders Rich Gelson (formerly of Pilgrim, and now in the Presbytery of Northeast New Jersey), and Robin Palmer Burton (Highlands) for their important service to the Presbytery. Not only did they serve as commissioners to General Assembly, but they made recommendations on concurrences before the Assembly, and more recently met to offer their recommendations on the matters coming before the Presbytery this year. Ruling Elder and Teaching Elder Commissioners to the Presbytery were reminded that the Presbytery will be electing Commissioners to the 2026 General Assembly in Milwaukee, and encouraged their prayerful discernment as to whether they are called to that vital role. Information will be forthcoming.
Of the thirteen items to be voted upon, all but 24-A and 24-C were placed before the Presbytery for action. Of the remaining eleven, only 24-L, concerning the paid or unpaid nature of administrative leave, was voted against. Because of the complexities involved in each of these matters, those wishing to learn more about any of the amendments, including 24-A and 24-C which are up for a vote in May, are encouraged to go here. Voting report totals from across the denomination, as of the end of March, can be found here.
Following reports from other guests and speakers (found below), the meeting’s business was concluded. As for its four faithful years as Highlands Presbytery, that is best celebrated by living into its fifth and future years just as faithfully.
Pastors in New Roles
Rev. Heather Morrison Yaden, Interim pastor, Long Valley Presbyterian Church
Rev. Michael Cuppett, Pastor, First Presbyterian Church of Newton
Rev. Emily Mccachren, Covenant Supply Pastor, Frenchtown Presbyterian Church
Rev. Peter Billings At-Large Minister, Director Of Family And Community Ministries – Hilltop Church, First Presbyterian, Mendham
65 SUMMERS OF CAMP JOHNSONBURG
Executive Director Elise Bates Russell brought the wonderful news that its capital campaign has successfully been completed.
There are now less than three months until registration opens for summer camp. You can see the video celebrating 65 Summers of Johnsonburg and get information on registration and other events here.
NAIROBI PARTNERSHIP
Ruling Elder Nancy Steiner (Wharton United), a member of the Nairobi Partnership shared statistics and successes of the 30 year partnership between Highlands and Nairobi Presbyteries. In that time, there have been 116 Presbytery travelers from 31 congregations, and 71 Kenya Partnerships, which have resulted in joint projects totaling $1,700,000 in ministries of health, education, and job creation. You can see the presentation slides here.
Highlands Presbytery will continue to accept gifts for the Nairobi Partnership until December 31, 2025. You can make an online donation here, or checks can be sent to the Presbytery at Highlands Presbytery of NJ, 390 Route 10, Randolph, NJ 07869.
NOMINATING COMMITTEE
Rev. Amy Lincoln (Flemington) nominated two more people to the Presbytery’s Commission on Ministry, but there is a need for more hands on deck for that and other commissions, committees, and teams in Highlands Presbytery. If you are sensing a call to serve the church beyond your congregation, contact the Presbytery here.
YOUNG LEADER FORMATION TEAM
Rev. Tim Clarkson (Denville/Presbyterian & Succasunna/First) presented a report on the recent Family Spirituality Day, held at Camp Johnsonburg. You can learn more here. He also called attention to the Presbyterian Youth Triennium and its upcoming registration deadline. More information is available here.
Upcoming 2025 Stated Meetings
May 13, 4PM, Hybrid
(Zoom and Johnsonburg)
September 9, 4PM, Hybrid
(Zoom and Johnsonburg)
November 11, 7PM, Zoom
The Clergy Care Fund
The Clergy Care Fund assists pastors in times of crisis and emergency. Gifts may be given
online by
- using the QR Code below
- going to the Highlands Presbytery website here
- texting “PRESBY Meeting” to 73256
or sending a check to Presbytery of the Highlands, 390 Route 10 West, Randolph, NJ 07869, and putting “Clergy Care Fund” in the Memo Line.















